237 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215 (347) 599-1913
237 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215 (347) 599-1913
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

  • Slide 1 of 6
  • Slide 2 of 6
  • Slide 3 of 6
  • Slide 4 of 6
  • Slide 5 of 6
  • Slide 6 of 6

    • Pizza

    Specialty Pies

    • Seasonal White Pie

      Fresh figs, hot honey

      $38

    • Seasonal White Pie

      ‘Nduja, fresh figs, hot honey

      $42

    Toppings

    Topping are available for whole and 1/2 pies. Prices listed are for 1/2 pies.

    • Select up to 2 Toppings

      Shallots $2

      Roasted Mushrooms $3

      Roni Cups $3

      Artisan Sausage $3

      Homemade Meatball $3

      Roni Cups and Shallots $4

      Don Vito (artisan Sausage and Shallots) $4

      Roasted Mushrooms and Shallots $4

      Homemade Meatball and Shallots $4

      Roni Cups and Artisan Sausage $5

      Roni Cups and Roasted Mushrooms $5

      Artisan Sausage and Roasted Mushrooms $5

      Homemade Meatball and Ricotta $5

      Meat Lover's (meatball, Sausage, Roni Cups) $6

    Standard Pies

    • Vegan Giusepp'

      NY style pie, fresh tomato sauce, fresh basil, miyoko's creamery vegan cheese. Finished with oregano, evoo

      $31

    • Nonna Mena (Grandma)

      $32

    • Pizza Bianca (White Pie)

      $32

    • DOP Sicilian

      Regular

      Upside Down

      $35

    • Giusepp' (NY Style)

      $25

    • La Regina Margherita

      $30

    Not Pizza

    • Garlic Knot Meatball Sliders

      Order of 4

      $15

    • Garlic Knots

      Order of 4

      $3.50

    • Housemade Artisan Bread

      Loaf

      $8

    • Pinwheel Special

      $4.25

    • Plate of Meatballs

      $12

    • Garlic Knot Meatball Sliders

      Order of 2

      $8

    • Garlic Knot

      Single

      $1

    • Meatball Hero

      $15

    • Dough Ball

      4 day fermented dough, 625g

      $5

    Salads & Sides

    • The Every Pizzeria Salad

      A not so standard, standard salad. Marinated tomatoes, cucumbers and shallots over a bed of whatever greens are the freshest available, tossed with wine vinegar and extra virgin olive oil.

      $8

      dairy free, peanut free, tree nut free, gluten free, vegetarian, vegan

    • Side of Sauce

      $0.75

    Drinks

    • Lurisia Sparkling Water

      $4

    • PullicenHell Bottle

      Amber ale

      $10

    • #Cuoredinapoli Bottle

      Pale ale

      $10

    Download PDF

    Salad

    Ask about our seasonal salads*

    • The Every Pizzeria Salad

      Marinated tomatoes, cucumbers, and shallots over a bed of seasonal greens tossed in our house vinaigrette

      $8

    • Arugula Salad

      Arugula, shaved parmigiano, pickled shallots, house vinaigrette

      $12

    • Caprese Salad

      Fresh mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, aged balsamic, EVOO

      $12

    Desserts

    • Cannolo Siciliano

      Crispy 6 inch cannolo shell with dark chocolate coated interior, filled with sheep-milk ricotta, finished with candied orange peel

      $6.50

    • Tiramisu Cup

      Coffee and zabaione cream on a layer of sponge cake soaked in espresso, dusted with cocoa powder

      $6.50

    • Triple Chocolate Gelato

      Layers of dark and white chocolate gelato topped with milk chocolate curls

      $6

    • Strawberry & Mascarpone Gelato

      Layers of dark and white chocolate gelato topped with milk chocolate curls

      $6

    Wine

    • Fabrizio Vella

      Wild fermented in acacia barrels and left on the skin for 5 days, then aged in steel with minimal sulfur added. Well rounded orchard fruit with candied orange zest and wild herbs

      Bottle $40

    • Integrale Frizzante Rose

      Grapes are refermented in the bottle after primary tank fermentation. Aromas of currants and cherries followed by rose and violets. The palate is fresh and slightly dry

      Bottle $38

    Craft Beers

    • Birra Dolomiti Rossa

      Brewed with foraged wild hops, indigenous to Italy, with locally farmed barley, it is used to give this pilsner-style beer its distinctive flavor

      $8

    • Birra Dolomiti Pils

      Lound, elegant flavor and creamy foam with floral notes. Made with dolomite barley malt. Light, refreshing taste

      $8

    • Forst Premium Lager

      Light, fresh beer with an unmistakable floral aroma. Lively, pleasant, and effortless, perfect for a casual drink with friends or to complement a quick bite

      $8

    Soft Drinks

    • A' Siciliana Orange Soda

      $3.50

    • A' Siciliana Lemon Soda

      $3.50

    • Mexican Coke

      $3.50

    • Apple Juice

      $3.50

    • Ginger Ale

      $2

    • Water Bottle

      $2

    Standard Pies

    • Giusepp' (NY Style)

      Fresh tomato sauce, fresh torn basil, premium aged mozzarella. Finished with sicilian oregano & aged romano. (vegan available)*

      $25

      vegetarian

    • Pizza Bianca (White Pie)

      Premium aged & fresh mozzarella, finished with whipped ricotta, sicilian oregano, lemon zest, cracked black pepper, 24 month aged parmigiano reggiano, partanna EVOO

      $32

      vegetarian

    • Nonna Mena (Grandma)

      Our signature dough pressed into an oiled pan, sliced fresh mozzarella, garlic, basil confit tomato sauce, finished with sicilian oregano, fresh torn basil, 24-month aged parmigiano, partanna EVOO

      $32

    • La Regina Margherita

      Premium aged mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, topped with our signature fresh tomato sauce. Finished with sicilian oregano, fresh torn basil, 24 month aged parmigiano reggiano, partanna EVOO

      $30

      vegetarian

    • D.O.P. Sicilian

      Premium aged mozzarella, cooked tomato sauce, cheese crust. Finished with sicilian oregano, fresh torn basil, aged romano partanna EVOO

      $35

      vegetarian

    • Toppings

      $3 per each

      Pepperoni Cups

      Faicco's Sausage

      Roasted Cremini Mushrooms

      Roasted Broccoli

      Garlic Confit

      Marinated Shallots

      Housemade Meatballs

      Ricotta

      Roasted Peppers

    • Premium Toppings

      $5 per each

      Anchovies

      'Nduja (Spicy Sausage)

      Spicy Soppressata (Salami)

    Specialty Pies

    Ask about seasonal pies*

    • Don Vito Grandma

      Our first specialty pie from the pop-up days. Grandma pizza topped with faicco's sausage and marinated shallots

      $35

    • Spicy Margherita

      Spicy version of our la Regina margherita with flatiron pepper flakes, topped with roasted mushrooms and marinated shallots

      $32

      vegetarian

    • Santa Lucia

      Faicco's sausage, house roasted and pickled peppers, marinated shallots, fresh & smoked mozzarella, finished with 24 month parmigiano reggiano, EVOO, and parsley

      $25

    • Make Any Pie with Vegan Cheese

      Add + $8

    Not Pizza

    • Pinwheels - Pepperoni

      Housemade dough, marinated shallots, pepperoni, mozzarella, toasted sesame seed crust

      $4.25

    • Pinwheels - Broccoli

      Housemade dough, roasted broccoli, garlic confit, mozzarella

      $4.25

      vegetarian

    • Garlic Knot Meatball Sliders

      House recipe meatballs, with mozzarella & tomato sauce, and our housemade garlic knots

      (2) $8

      (4) $15

    • Meatball Hero

      House recipe meatballs, with mozzarella & tomato sauce, and our housemade garlic knots

      $8

    • Meatball Plate

      House recipe meatballs, with mozzarella & tomato sauce, and our housemade garlic knots

      $12

    • Calzone

      Baked to golden, delightful blend of smoked mozzarella, whipped ricotta, and stracciatella

      $12

      vegetarian

    • Mortadella Sandwich

      Mortadella, stracciatella, arugula and pesto on housemade focaccia

      $15

    • Focaccia

      14 Inch round dimpled and hearth baked to order with EVOO, herb medley, and finishing salt

      $7

      vegetarian

    • Garlic Knot

      Light, puffy knots with homemade dough served with a side of our house tomato sauce

      $1

      vegetarian

    • Side Of Sauce

      each $2

    • Mike's Hot Honey 1 Oz

      $2 per each

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!